Sarah McCarty,

Sarah McCarty

Cell Phone: 812-593-5776
Email: sarah.mccarty@bhhsutah.com
Find your home's value: https://sarahmccarty.realscout.com/whats-my-home-worth
Office Location: 2200 Park Avenue, Park City

For more than 25 years, my career has been centered on people—understanding what matters to them, building genuine relationships, and helping them make important decisions. With a background in business, education, sales, and strategic partnerships, I bring a thoughtful, practical approach to real estate.

Having called Park City home since 2014 and personally invested in real estate, I understand how personal real estate decisions can be. I take the time to listen, ask questions, and understand what matters most, so my clients feel comfortable and informed every step of the way.

Whether I’m working with a first-time buyer, a seller, or a seasoned investor, my goal is simple: to be someone my clients can trust, count on, and have in their corner. For me, real estate is ultimately about people—and the relationships that last well beyond the closing.

Office Listings

302 White Pine Canyon Road, Park City
Active

$28,200,000

302 White Pine Canyon Road, Park City

7 Beds 10 Baths 16,716 SqFt Residential 12603288

J. Stephen Jeffers BHHS Utah Properties - SV

269 White Pine Canyon Road, Park City
Pending

$27,500,000

269 White Pine Canyon Road, Park City

6 Beds 9 Baths 11,132 SqFt Residential 12602886

J. Stephen Jeffers BHHS Utah Properties - SV

2322 N Westward Ho Road, Heber City
Active

$27,500,000

↑ $8,000,000

2322 N Westward Ho Road, Heber City

7 Beds 8 Baths 17,568 SqFt Residential 12601487

Matthew Mullin BHHS Utah Properties - SV

1790 Bonanza Drive, Park City
Active

$19,500,000

↑ $17,300,000

1790 Bonanza Drive, Park City

Commercial Sale 12603761

Katie Wilking BHHS Utah Properties - SV

6101 Golf Club Link, Park City
Active

$19,500,000

6101 Golf Club Link, Park City

5 Beds 9 Baths 10,769 SqFt Residential 12603673

Ryan Mclaughlin BHHS Utah Properties - SV

3611 Crestwood Court, Park City
Active Under Contract

$17,500,000

3611 Crestwood Court, Park City

6 Beds 10 Baths 14,289 SqFt Residential 12603282

Jacquelyn Harris Grayson BHHS Utah Properties - SV

9156 N Sleeping Rock Circle, Kamas
Active

$16,900,000

9156 N Sleeping Rock Circle, Kamas

7 Beds 11 Baths 11,775 SqFt Residential 12502872

Tyler Richardson BHHS Utah Properties - SV

23 Sandstone Cove, Park City
Active

$16,800,000

23 Sandstone Cove, Park City

7 Beds 9 Baths 13,835 SqFt Residential 12602812

Steve Chin BHHS Utah Properties - SV

12945 E Forest Creek Road, Heber City
Active

$16,500,000

12945 E Forest Creek Road, Heber City

7 Beds 8 Baths 11,410 SqFt Residential 12603036

Matthew Mullin BHHS Utah Properties - SV

182 White Pine Canyon Road, Park City
Active

$14,250,000

182 White Pine Canyon Road, Park City

5 Beds 6 Baths 7,724 SqFt Residential 12603771

Bronson Calder BHHS Utah Properties - SV

2300 S Deer Valley Drive 808, Park City
Active

$13,800,000

2300 S Deer Valley Drive 808, Park City

4 Beds 5 Baths 3,517 SqFt Residential 12603564

Jacquelyn Harris Grayson BHHS Utah Properties - SV

2580 Larkspur Drive, Park City
Active

$13,500,000

2580 Larkspur Drive, Park City

5 Beds 5 Baths 6,249 SqFt Residential 12603369

Katy Mullin Patterson BHHS Utah Properties - SV

Get to know Sarah

What are you known for?

What are you known for?

Being accountable, smiling, and genuinely caring about people.

Born in

Born in

Indiana

Languages

Languages

English

Proudest moment

Proudest moment

Being a mom to four amazing adult sons is one of my greatest sources of pride. Professionally, being named Teacher of the Year was incredibly meaningful because it represented something I have always valued—making a difference in the lives of others. I'm proud of the career I've built, but I'm even more proud of the relationships and people I've had the opportunity to partner with along the way.

Hardest thing you've ever done

Hardest thing you've ever done

I spent seven days rafting and camping through Montana’s Bob Marshall Wilderness with my husband and friends. We rode horses for 30 miles, paddled the river 12-15 miles a day, fly-fished for dinner, and camped in grizzly country. It was one of the hardest things I’ve ever done—and one of the most rewarding.

Perfect day

Perfect day

A perfect work day for me starts with coffee and some quiet time, followed by time with friends, family, or clients. I love a day filled with laughter, meaningful conversations, and time to relax and recharge. My favorite escape days are at the beach relaxing, soaking up the warmth from the sun, reading a book and collecting seashells.

Best gift you've ever received

Best gift you've ever received

Anything homemade. I've always loved gifts that come from the heart, especially the things my sons, family, and friends have made for me. To me, those gifts are priceless --they're about the thought, time, and love behind them. Those are the things I treasure most.

First job

First job

My first job out of college was at State Farm selling insurance.

Secret talent

Secret talent

I'm a plant propagating enthusiast! I love taking plants and creating new ones from cuttings, especially succulents. Once I've propagated enough, I create succulent arrangements and give them away to others. There's something really satisfying about watching something grow from a tiny cutting into something beautiful—and even better when I get to share it with someone else.

Define success

Define success

To me, success is about relationships, impact, and living a life you genuinely enjoy. It's knowing that you've been there for people, kept your word, listened when it mattered, and helped make someone's journey a little easier.

What do you love about Utah?

What do you love about Utah?

I love skiing, hiking, biking, paddle boarding, fishing, and outdoor concerts. Park City offers such an incredible combination of natural beauty, adventure, community, and culture. Most of all, I love that there's always something to explore and someone to share it with. That's what makes Park City feel like home.